As many of you know my grandmother, Mary Kleinhandler was a source of great love and inspiration for me. She passed away on April 16th at 10:02 pm. I am posting her eulogies in the order they were read at her funeral, for those of you who are interested in learning a bit more about this extraordinary woman.
Mom: Eulogy. Mary Kleinhandler
December 22, 1920 – April 16, 2011
From Daughter Henriette Kleinhandler
This is a very sad time of loss for all of us. My mother, Mary, was vibrant, brilliant, highly educated, generous, and loving. Mary was a free spirit. Her sense of humor and sparkle lit the light of life in us all. She suffered through the ordeals of the Holocaust, cancer, open heart surgery, diabetes, and the death of our father, Arthur. But she had tenacity and strength and gave us hope to overcome the hardships in life. As she would say, “Make yourself strong. This too shall pass.” She also cherished the joys of living. My mom loved us all, me, Susie and Mitch, Cherie and Ron, Aimee and David, and especially her great grand children Rose, Ava, and Kaleb. Her family, our cousin Barbara, and friends always held a special place in her heart.
I would just like to share some memories of my mother that will stay with me forever. These are the images of love.
I remember when we were small children my mother would hold our hands and together Susie and I would go with her into the garden. She delighted in teaching us the names of all the beautiful flowers and pick cherries from the tree. We would intensely study the strawberry patch and her vegetable garden. One of the things that kept her alive during the suffering of the Holocaust was the image of an idyllic garden, just like the one in Chmielnik at her grandmother’s house, she and fulfilled that dream. Her garden symbolized survival, renewal, and life.
I remember the wonderful stories she would tell us of her summers in the mountains picking mushrooms or going to Chmielnik. She loved her grandparents and played with her first cousins Zlatcha, Barbara, and her brother, Karol.
I remember sitting at the kitchen table with our mom, Susie, and our grandma Ruth and laughing at the jokes and one liners till tears rolled down our checks. I remember her repartee with Alfred Rozenek and who could be the funniest.
I remember how beautifully she sang. My parents would sing songs in harmony-- Yiddish, English and Polish. She would also sing in German and Russian for she spoke six languages. Sometimes my grandma would play the mandolin or violin and they would sing together. Those were wonderful times.
I remember how she read all the classics and existential philosophy. She would recite entire passages of poetry in Latin and Goethe’s Faust in German. She loved to read and always had a book next to her. In fact, she was so impressed and excited by some novels, that she would tell me the whole story before I read the book. She was very proud of her Classical Education and that she had successfully graduated 14th grade, the equivalent of Jr. College.
I remember how she loved to dress up and go out. She was very beautiful with turquoise blue eyes and champagne silvery hair. As a child I remember her delicate complexion contrasting with her striking long black hair that she would twist into a French knot.
She loved our dad Arthur and they were inseparable They were married for 63 years and when he passed in 2006 she always missed him terribly and would look at his picture every night before she went to bed, till the last week of her life. Every weekend my parents would go on long bike rides from Santa Monica to the Marina or walk in Santa Monica with their close friends Cesia and Isaac Ulman, Lola and Adam Crispo, Alfred and Lola Rozenek, and Rena and David Goldstein. They had deep discussions and much laughter. Then they would enjoy a wonderful brunch. My mother loved these outings. She also loved the many adventures traveling throughout the world. At the end of her life she also loved her caregivers Raquel, Tina, Alene. And we all tried to give her a good quality of life which she always enjoyed.
Finally, I will always remember that my mom called me every single morning and she would sing me a song like “If I were a rich man”, wish me a gutten Shabbish, and tell me that everything is under control—until it wasn’t. She would always say “What are our plans for today? I’ll go wherever you go and then we’ll have lunch.” And then she would say, “I love you forever.”
Mom, I love YOU forever. Your image is in my soul and you will always be alive in my heart. Henriette
******************************************************************************************************************************
I Love You Forever
From Mitch Golant
Context is everything: For the last decade Mary would greet me with the following: “Oh…Mitchie…Mitchie…I love you forever. You are my son—Not my son-in-law. I love you forever.” It was delivered in the declarative—with absolute certainty. I was 19 years old when I met Susie. We married when I was 22. What I am sharing comes from the perspective of a child growing up in two worlds. The world of my childhood and the world of the Shoah. After all these years, I struggled with this recurring question: Does the Holocaust Trump All?
Let’s take even an example from Monty Python, “No one expects the Spanish Inquisition.” …Unless you are a Holocaust Survivor…where your worst fears were realized. Trump.
However, as I have come to understand now, Mary’s life as embodied in the simple but profound sentiment: “I love you forever!”actually trumps all. This occurs in four ways—through: (1) Moral integrity (2) Humor (3) Spirituality, and (4) Love
Moral Integrity
Mary never wanted a housekeeper. Even as she began to slow down, she reluctantly accepted help but only for ½ day a week. On Wednesdays when Lorena would come, Mary would still do the laundry: She said, “Why should I have her clean my dirty clothes and sheets?” At Noon Mary would cook lunch for them both. We just didn’t get it until in a flash I understood--she was a house slave for the SS at the Villa Versailles (chronicled in her memoir)—cleaning their clothes, laundry and shining their boots. Mary could not tolerate or fathom the idea that anyone was below her and she felt a moral imperative to hold to the idea that we were all creatures that share this earth and that no one is better or should serve another. It was out of this deep sense of moral and ethical integrity that lunch was served and housework was shared. Trump.
Humor:
In the summer of 1974, Mary, Arthur and I would ride our 3-speed bikes along the Venice/Santa Monica beach bike bath. On this Sunday, Mary and I were riding alone along the bike path and we had it in our mind with mischievous eye to ride past the Venice nude beach. As Mary tells the story, “Mitch was riding behind me and then he was looking at the naked women and he rode right off the bike path and falling into the sand.” In truth. I was riding on the bike path and Mary stopped her bike pointing to what I learned later was what she described as a “naked white male albino guerilla” and wanted to show me. To avoid colliding with her I dumped my bike into the sand. When she explained, I said, “That’s why you stopped?” I said, “I’m more interested in naked women than naked albino guerilla men.” She says, “I’m going to tell Susie!” I say, “I’m going to tell Arthur.” We both burst out laughing. Trump
Spirituality
Of course, there is an important distinction between spirituality and the religiosity. Mary had a porous relationship between the here and the hereafter. She felt a deep connection to all life through dreams, waking dreams, and premonitions that sustained her through adversity. There are so many examples—Sue has already shared one. The one example that stays with me was when she had bypass surgery and it didn’t go well. She needed blood and Sue rushed to donate. When she made it through the crisis we explained that she nearly died. She said, I already knew that. We asked: “How did you know.” She said, “Well, I was in a dream and I saw my parents and my brother and I started running towards them because I was so happy to see them. My mother turned to me and said, “Stop! Go back. It’s not your time yet.” They all turned their backs on me. So I turned around and then I woke up here. “ She tells that story with certainty and faith that this experience is a link between us and those who come before us and as a legacy for us to cherish. Trump
Love
As you know Mary died the evening after Shabbat Hagadol. The Shabbat that precedes Passover. Mary loved Passover. It was her holiday. Each Passover she would tell the same story and it would start with, “We were slaves in Egypt and now we are free. I was once a slave and now I am free. I didn’t know whether I could have children. And I had children. She would point to Henrie and Susie. Then my children had children—Cherie and Aimee. And now my grandchildren have children—Rosie, Ava and Kaleb (who is named after my brother Karol) and then she would cry. I am grateful for my life and that I live in this country free. I love you forever!
Taken together—moral integrity with a light touch through humor impassioned by a vibrant spiritual life stitched together with love trumps all. As Alfred Rozenek aliva shalom said nearly 5 years ago to your beloved Avrum, I say to you today….Shalom My Friend. I will love you forever! Amen
******************************************************************************************************************************
From Cherie Golant, Granddaughter
She’s the reason I’m here. Her survival ensured my existence.
I grew up knowing that my being in her life was one of her paramount joys. She adored me, and I felt the same. Even in the end, when dementia kept her mind moving in tight circles, she never held back expressions of love. I remember growing up, her stopping everything to pour love on one or another of us. Her love and gratitude to reach this day, this moment, to have us in her life was declared regularly. To feel her love wash over me, I would also know that by giving love, by showing love, and sharing love, she was experiencing great joy.
In recovery from breast cancer surgery in 1972, my grandma felt sure she was dying. She had a dream of a small hand pulling her away from death. She always told me this, that it was me who brought her back to life. She had me to look forward to, and my sister to come the next year, and nearly 40 more years of love and moments of joy. Our bat mitzvahs, graduations, weddings, and the birth of her great grand children. The holding of babies gave her a unique pleasure, a glow. It used to be that we worked hard to avoid causing her any pain, but eventually, bringing her pleasure became its own reward.
When I saw her this week before she died, I told her again and again how much I loved her. How her brother, mother and grandparents were waiting for her, along with my grandpa. And that when she saw them, she should tell them how much we loved her.
She is the reason I’m here. Her survival ensured my existence. Learning to live without her starts today.
******************************************************************************************************************************
From Aimee Golant, Granddaughter
There is no explaining how my grandparents have affected my life. I will try today, but really there is nothing I can say that will capture my feelings for them. I say grandparents and not grandmother, because for me no matter how different they were from one another, it is hard to separate them.
I talk about my grandparents every day in my work. Their life has given mine meaning, direction, and purpose. At the Passover seder each year, my grandma would declare that we were once slaves and now we are free! This was our holiday. It was real. She would say that she survived for the family and that every day she lived was a victory over Nazi brutality.
Their survival of spirit, their inner strength, and perseverance inspired me to create Judaica-- Jewish Ritual Objects. It is in their honor that I create Judaica-- using my grandfather’s tools. Not Judaica of reverence to G-d, but Judaica of survival, of preserving tradition, of sharing our universal teachings with Jews and non-Jews and thereby fighting anti-semitism.
My grandmother had wisdom. When she spoke, I listened. Anytime I have been faced with a life challenge, when I feel defeated or unsure, I remember the words my grandma told me. She would look at me with those piercing blue eyes and say: “BE STRONG,” and “if you don’t know what to do, DO NOTHING. The answers will come.” I can’t tell you how many times I would think about my life situation, and compare, just for a second what she endured in her life and figure, if she could survive that-- I can do this. I swear, she has at times given me super powers.
These words of wisdom remind me of a story she once told, shortly after my grandfather passed away in 2006. She pulled out a silver 1943 Liberty Half Dollar Coin. After the war, within a week of arriving in New York, my grandfather right away found work at a gas station. He thought he had been hired as a mechanic to work on the cars, turns out he was pumping gas. The first week on the job, a man gave him that coin as a tip. It was a huge dollar amount at that time-- enough for a week’s groceries. My grandpa brought the coin home to my grandma. They sat in amazement, in silence, in tears. Quite incredibly, they never spent the money-- she had saved it to this day. She told us that she wanted to be buried with the coin. The thought of it, made us all groan. But then I thought, who am I to question what she wants? So, I took the coin and fashioned a silver and gold locket for it, which I gave to her about a year ago. I would love to show you all the coin and box, but today, as per her wish, I put the coin in it’s silver box with her in the casket. It was a testament to their temperance, strength and gratitude.
Finally, she has passed on an appreciation for the simple things in life-- the smell of home cooking (love thick in the air) the sheer miracle of being together with family, gratitude for living in America-- a free and diverse country, a love of nature, a responsibility to take care of my body. The best I can do is pass on their values and their Legacy of love and gratitude to my family-- my husband David and Son Kaleb. I will never stop grieving them, I will love them forever.
******************************************************************************************************************************
Mary Kleinhandler
From Susan Golant, Daughter
After one of her closest friends died, my mother pulled me aside in the chapel right after the service and whispered, “When I die, don’t you dare talk about what a good cook I was.” So I promised that I wouldn’t mention her stuffed cabbage and honey cakes and cookies and kreplach. I would not bring up her blueberry turnovers or her mushroom barley soups or her Friday night latkes sprinkled with poppy seeds—perfectly crispy on the outside and creamy within.
A puzzling request to some, maybe, but I understood it full well. Yes, she was a wonderful homemaker, but she was so much more than that. A free spirit, a towering intellect, a jokester and prankster. A woman who suffered incalculable pain and loss but also found ways to enjoy the life that she was given, even in the smallest ways. She took such pleasure in her garden, her books, her grandchildren. White sheets flapping in the summer breeze, smelling sweetly of sunshine were a numinous delight, to be gathered in the arms and inhaled with great rapture. The ability to pour a capful of bleach into the toilet bowl and swish it around, to mop the floor and wash the windows--these were sources of deep joy and gratitude, a reason to sing out gaily. Scenes I had observed when I was a child.
She carried the burdens of her life with dignity and honesty, speaking out when she felt the need. In the late 1950s, the City of New York was planning to build the Clearview Expressway right though our neighborhood. Our home in Bayside along with all the others in the path of the new road was slated to be torn down. She attended a hearing at City Hall and stood up to speak to Mayor Robert Wagner, her long black hair done up in a French Twist, her aquamarine blue eyes flashing. The Long Island Star Journal showed her photo and quoted her as saying, “We were dispossessed once in our lives. The Nazis took everything from us—our homes, our families, our lives. Please don’t do this to us again.”
We lost, of course. As they say, you can’t fight City Hall—especially in NY. But still, she was strong in ways that I could not even imagine and vulnerable and hurt in ways that could never be healed.
An utterly unique and complex individual who always marched to her own drummer, she never went along with the crowd, just to get along. She wasn’t cowed by conventionality the way my father was—and they fought about it. It was very important to him what people would think. She really didn’t care. She loved bright splashy colors and big floral prints—he was into brown and tan and navy polka dots—and they fought about that too. But it didn’t mean very much. They were devoted to each other in ways we could never fathom—he having saved her life and she having saved his during the war. Each one a hero to the other until the end.
There were times when she seemed luminescent. Glowing with love, with a hunger for life, for experience. She was behind all the trips my parents took. Each year when they flew either to Israel or Argentina to visit my father’s siblings she would say, “Let’s stop in London for a week.” Or Spain, or Greece, or France. Or Uruguay or Venezuela. They started traveling in earnest after my father retired--to China and Thailand and Japan; to Russia and Scandinavia; to Italy and Romania numerous times for mineral baths. She sampled barbecued lizard on a stick and mysterious fruits in Asia, and octopus and “every part of the bull” in Argentina proudly telling us about her adventures. And each time they brought back a bounty of gifts for the family—a way that they could share their travels with us—embroidered tablecloths, crystal vases, silk kimonos, jewelry--treasures from their generous souls.
She studied Renoir and Picasso and Leger on her own. She read Henry Miller’s Tropic of Cancer (I found it under her side of the bed wrapped in brown paper) and John Updike and Saul Bellow and Philip Roth—that mixed in with Dostoyevsky and Tolstoy. My mother often spoke of her education, her difficulties in math, her love of poetry and philosophy. In Poland she had read Shakespeare and Dickens, Zola and Proust in translation. Her favorite poets were the Polish Romantic, Mickiewicz, whom she referred to and recited frequently and Goethe, whom she had memorized in German. In fact, she had studied German for twelve years, Latin for eight, and Hebrew for four. Many were the times she recited Latin poetry to me, translating as she went along.
Manya Scheiber was born late in December of 1920, and by her accounts was a mischievous, willful, and curious child. She teased her younger brother mercilessly and once threw a fork at her uncle's forehead when he threatened her. A self-avowed tomboy, we have many pictures of her climbing trees. She continued that athleticism into late adulthood. I think my parents stopped going to the gym when she was in her 80s and my father decided he didn’t want to drive anymore.
She was also quite beautiful. She had inherited her father's porcelain skin and linear nose. Her jet-black hair was straight, and shiny, and cut short like a "Chinaman's," as she used to say. (By the war's end, at the age of twenty-five, it had turned mostly white.)
Her most striking features, however, were those brown-flecked aquamarine eyes, which at times appear almost hypnotic. The right eye was larger than the left. It looked out on the world, while the other narrowed and seems always to survey the inner landscape of her soul. Her eyes were expressive and clear, affording anyone who had the inclination, an opportunity to catch a glimpse of that inner terrain too and the trembling pain that it held.
Although she always downplayed it, my mother believed that she had psychic abilities. I remember once she sat straight up in bed at 2 AM and said with great foreboding and certitude, "Somebody has died." She was right. At that moment, my father's mother, Chaya, had passed away while visiting her daughter in Buenos Aires.
I learned to trust my mother's "feelings," as she called her premonitions and moments of intuition, but I also came to believe that at times she could see right through me. We were bound up, one with the other so tightly that sometimes it was difficult for me to know where I ended and she began. And, in truth, it was difficult for her too.
There is so much to say and yet I feel I can’t capture it all. Ninety years is a long time to live and my mother’s life was so eventful—filled with great tragedy and triumph. She wrote a 225 page memoir with me that delineates her wartime experiences so it’s impossible for me to distill it down to a brief timeline of events or an enumeration of the camps she had survived during those terrible times. I am happy to email it to everyone here if you want to know the details. Just ask. A few words, though about the war. My mother spoke of it constantly. She was not one of those survivors who kept that part of her life hidden. I believe it was because she had no shame about the experience. As she always said, “We didn’t step on anyone.” Indeed, she bravely saved the lives of two strangers, putting herself at risk. She scorned those who were selfish and championed their own survival over others. She had no tolerance for hypocrites. And she never stopped grieving for her younger brother who died within days of the War’s end. Yet despite all that had happened to her, hers was a loving and generous heart.
In the last two years, as vascular dementia overtook her wonderful mind and all of the filters began to disappear, she would declare, “I am a genius.” Probably she was, though the traumas she had endured most likely thwarted her ability to use her intellect on a greater stage. And then she would say, “Not a moment of my life is lost. I remember everything.” I guess the best that I could hope for is that not a moment of my life with her would be lost to me. Still I know that she is in me, a part of me, and will always be. She is in my children. The love and affection I see them give to their babies—passed from her through me to them. The gardening, the hiking in the forest, the carefree days at the beach, the books, the kindness and generosity, the big heart, the sensitivity, they all came from her.
During a Bar Mitzvah we literally pass the Torah from one generation to the next. L’dor va dor—from generation to generation. In our family, we pass her love.